BITO

Why are brands still discounting blind?

Retail media has transformed how brands spend their advertising budgets. So why are pricing and promotions still so opaque, asks James Taylor, Founder and CEO of Particular Audience?

Retail media has transformed the way brands buy advertising. It has made targeting, measurement and optimisation standard, with campaigns that can be adjusted as they run, rather than needing to be locked in weeks in advance. Yet there is a much bigger part of the retail trade equation that still works in a very different way: pricing and promotions.

In terms of how it is administered and delivered, trade marketing is still stuck in the ’90s. It is opaque to brands, and there is limited targeting, barely any measurement and huge upfront commitments. Brands agree a promotion, set the discount and commit the money, often without knowing exactly what outcome they are going to get. Once it is running, there is very little ability to react when the market changes.

That is a strange situation for an industry that has spent the last decade making advertising more data-driven, and even self-service. Retail media has shown what happens when you put transparency, targeting and measurement around media spend with retailers. The same thinking can be applied to the much larger pool of money (we estimate 5-6x) already being spent on pricing and promotions.

The problem with blind discounting

The biggest gap is in the discount itself: brands are still deciding how much to give away before they know what it will take to make the sale. And clearly, the point here is not to give a bigger discount; it is to give the right discount. If a retailer needs to offer 10% off to change a customer’s behaviour, then 10% may make sense. But if 7% will do, why give away 10%? And if 2.5% will do, as our data shows it can in certain contexts, why should brands still blanket discount blindly?

Historically, there has been no practical way to make that decision in real time. The result is blind: money is being put into promotions without knowing how much of that money is actually necessary to drive the sale, and seldom will brands truly get to isolate results from their investment.

Technology makes it possible to make that decision in real time. A brand could, for example, set a rule around a particular SKU and offer a 2.5% discount if that is enough to make the product competitive. Everyone who qualifies for that rule (time and competitor context) gets the same price: this isn’t personalised pricing that adjusts to individual customers; it’s SKU-based and contextual.

If the competitive situation changes, the promotion can change with it (in real time). The retailer can launch it, see what happens and adjust the parameters based on customer behaviour, competitor activity or external factors.

That ability to react makes a huge difference to a brand’s bottom line, because retail conditions shift constantly: consumer budgets change; competitors adjust their prices or launch promotions; stock levels rise and fall; the wider economy shifts. A promotion designed around what was true two weeks ago can be very different from the promotion you would want to run today.

Retail doesn’t stand still

For some products, the need for immediacy is obvious. Think about a perishable product. If you know you need to stimulate demand today because you’re holding too much inventory worth nothing a week from now, being able to react today is useful. Waiting three days to find out what happened, and then another three to change the promotion: much less so. The objective should be to react and affect change immediately. (And this doesn’t just apply to perishables: even a laptop is technologically devalued within 6-12 weeks.)

Brands need conversion rate optimisation tools too, critically brands and retailers need profit rate optimisation.

That is the thinking behind Trade Media. We originally started working on this problem through our Price Beat technology, which started with a relatively simple question: what happens when you can see competitive pricing in real time and respond to it?

The technology crawls competing sites and identifies when another retailer has a better price. If a discount is needed to beat or match that price, it can trigger one. If the retailer is already the cheapest, it can instead tell the customer that they are getting the best available deal. In some cases, we have seen SKU-level product page conversion increase by more than 300% when Price Beat was applied and by over 80% when the retailer was able to affirm that its price was already the lowest.

The important part is not the size of any individual uplift. It is the connection between the promotional decision and the customer behaviour it is intended to change. Instead of deciding on a blanket discount and hoping it works, you can make the discount responsive to what is actually happening.

That does not mean handing the keys to an algorithm. Retailers can set rules around how many discounts can be redeemed in a basket, how much can be discounted on an individual SKU and what is acceptable within profitability requirements and brand agreements. The technology simply gives them a level of control and responsiveness that has not really existed in coupons before.

A new model for trade media

For brands, the attraction is greater efficiency from supplier-funded promotional budgets. For retailers, there is an opportunity to offer suppliers something much more sophisticated than another promotional slot: a measurable, targetable and adjustable way of deploying money they are already spending.

There is also a strategic opportunity here for retailers, who are already sitting on significant supplier-funded promotional budgets. The question is whether those budgets continue to be managed through relatively inflexible processes, or whether retailers can offer suppliers a more dynamic way to deploy them.

We are not trying to make trade marketing look like retail media for the sake of it. But the real lesson from retail media is that when you make something transparent, measurable and adjustable, you can manage it much more effectively.

If technology can make promotional decisions more responsive and more precise, you can make the promotion more effective while minimising the cost of achieving the sale. The goal is simple: to drive sales without giving away more margin than you need to.

The retailers that adopt this first will win brand investment share from the retailers stuck in the old world of Trade Marketing.

Dorotape